Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights
Find the Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights – 4+ Quality Options from Leading Providers
1-4 out of 4 hotels
Sort by:
high popularity
- Price: low to high
- Price: high to low
- Guest rating: high to low
- Popularity: high to low
Hotel
8.6
Great2020 reviews10
MapView on map1500 yd from City Center1800 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 569
/night
The 4-star Shelter Island House Shelter Island Heights is located around 10 minutes by foot from Crescent Beach and comprises 11 rooms with modern comforts.
Guest house
7.6
Very good55 reviews10
From
US$ 358
/night
- Bicycle rentals available on-site
- Family rooms for larger groups
- Free private parking for guests
Bed & Breakfast
8.4
Great2828 reviews10
- Adirondack Chairs
- Personalized Service
- Local Dining
400 yd from City Center600 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 283
/night
- Intimate boutique atmosphere with historical charm
- King size beds for ultimate comfort
- Stunning creek views with outdoor seating
Bed & Breakfast
8.6
Great2020 reviews10
- On-site Gallery
- Spa Services
- Heated Pool
1400 yd from City Center1700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 262
/night
- On-site contemporary art gallery
- Private paradise near the Hamptons
- Luxurious spa services available
Saved
Save
Top Hotel Picks in Shelter Island Heights
How much is a room per night?
The hotels listed below are recommended for their proximity to Shelter Island beaches and parks, which are just minutes away. Average nightly rates start at $150, and many properties boast guest ratings of 8.0 or above.
3 star:
$150-$250
4 star:
$250-$400
5 star:
$400-$600
