Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights
Find the Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights – 20+ Quality Options from Leading Providers
1-27 out of 27 hotels
Sort by:
high popularity
- Price: low to high
- Price: high to low
- Guest rating: high to low
- Popularity: high to low
Hotel
MapView on map1500 yd from City Center1800 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 569
/night
The 4-star Shelter Island House Shelter Island Heights is located around 10 minutes by foot from Crescent Beach and comprises 11 rooms with modern comforts.
Hotel
MapView on map1600 yd from City Center1.1 mi from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 596
/night
- Vibrant party atmosphere with DJ events
- Unique European vibe and casual atmosphere
- On-site bar with self-produced Rose'
Inn
- On-site restaurant
- Golf course
- Sun terrace
100 yd from City Center700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 826
/night
- On-site golf course
- Pets allowed
- Welcome drink offered
Bed & Breakfast
- Adirondack Chairs
- Personalized Service
- Local Dining
400 yd from City Center600 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 458
/night
- Intimate boutique atmosphere with historical charm
- King size beds for ultimate comfort
- Stunning creek views with outdoor seating
Bed & Breakfast
- On-site Gallery
- Spa Services
- Heated Pool
1400 yd from City Center1700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 870
/night
- On-site contemporary art gallery
- Private paradise near the Hamptons
- Luxurious spa services available
Guest house
- Family Rooms
- Bicycle Rentals
- Free Parking
From
US$ 358
/night
- Bicycle rentals available on-site
- Family rooms for larger groups
- Free private parking for guests
Places to stay near Shelter Island Heights
Hotel
- Tennis Court
- Saltwater Pool
- Private Patios
6.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.5 mi from City Center
From
US$ 219
/night
- Harborside dining with local ingredients
- Private tennis court for guests
- Seasonal saltwater swimming pool
Hotel
- Private Beach
- Piano Bar
- Outdoor Pool
2.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.3 mi from City Center
From
US$ 541
/night
- Oceanfront rooms with private beach access
- Upscale dining featuring local seafood
- Live music events at Piano Bar
- Private Beach
- On-site Dining
- Bicycle Rental
1.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.3 mi from City Center
From
US$ 720
/night
- Bungalow-style accommodations for unique stays
- On-site restaurant 'Nookies' serves excellent food
- Direct beach access for recreational activities
Hotel
- Rooftop Lounge
- Snack Galley
- Pet-Friendly
1.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.3 mi from City Center
From
US$ 499
/night
- Stunning rooftop lounge with harbor views
- Complimentary baked goods throughout the day
- Galley kitchens stocked with snacks
Hotel
- Private beach
- Farm-to-table restaurant
- Event space
3.2 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.2 mi from City Center
From
US$ 407
/night
- Charming waterfront venue with private beach
- Farm-to-table cuisine with seasonal flavors
- Year-round events promoting local culture
Hotel
- On-site Spa
- Private Cottages
- Tennis Court
1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
From
US$ 334
/night
- Complimentary kayaking and paddleboarding available
- Historic charm with modern renovations
- Engaging evening s'mores at fire pits
Hotel
- Spa centre
- Heated pool
- Bicycle rental
1.3 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.3 mi from City Center
From
US$ 170
/night
- On-site spa centre for rejuvenation
- Outdoor heated swimming pool for families
- Bicycle rentals for exploring Greenport
Hotel
- On-site Restaurant
- Cocktail Bar
- Bicycle Rental
1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
From
US$ 514
/night
- Award-winning on-site restaurant
- Dog-friendly accommodations available
- Tucked in historic Sterling Square
Motel
- Beach Access
- Garden Area
- Family Rooms
3.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.1 mi from City Center
From
US$ 250
/night
- Beachfront location with stunning views
- Spacious accommodations with kitchenettes
- On-site picnic area for guests
Hotel
- Private Beach
- Fitness Centre
- Outdoor Pool
2.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.1 mi from City Center
From
US$ 1 117
/night
- Stunning beachfront access
- Inviting seasonal outdoor pool
- Helpful and friendly staff
Hotel
- Outdoor Pool
- Balcony Rooms
- Harborview Lounge
6.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights6.4 mi from City Center
From
US$ 600
/night
- Complimentary beach permits for local access
- Stunning harbor-view balconies and patios
- Personalized service from friendly staff
Bed & Breakfast
- Private Beach
- Canoe Rentals
- Bicycle Access
2.9 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.9 mi from City Center
From
US$ 325
/night
- Private beach access across the street
- Delicious daily changing breakfast options
- Beautifully maintained gardens with butterflies
Bed & Breakfast
- Family rooms
- Game room
- Garden views
1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
From
US$ 599
/night
- Bicycle rental for cycling enthusiasts
- Family rooms for groups and kids
- Garden views for relaxing atmosphere
- Outdoor pool
- Kitchenette
- Fire pit
2.8 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.8 mi from City Center
From
US$ 186
/night
- Complimentary weekend breakfast for guests
- Close proximity to local wineries
- Pet-friendly accommodations available
Bed & Breakfast
- Private Parking
- Garden Views
- Flat-Screen TV
3.8 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.8 mi from City Center
From
US$ 355
/night
- Scenic garden views from the property
- Adults-only peaceful atmosphere
- Diverse buffet breakfast options available
Bed & Breakfast
- Sun terrace
- Snack bar
- Concierge service
1.4 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.4 mi from City Center
From
US$ 447
/night
- Historic building with garden views
- On-site bicycle rental service available
- Sea views from private rooms
- Tennis court
- Garden views
- Bicycle rental
4.5 mi from Shelter Island Heights4.5 mi from City Center
From
US$ 507
/night
- Tennis court and outdoor dining area
- Garden-view rooms with private bathrooms
- On-site bicycle rental available
Bed & Breakfast
- Hot tub
- Yoga classes
- Tennis court
3.0 mi from Shelter Island Heights3.0 mi from City Center
From
US$ 406
/night
- On-site spa with diverse wellness services
- Historic building with garden views
- Tennis court and cycling excursions available
Bed & Breakfast
- Outdoor jacuzzi
- Private parking
- Garden terrace
5.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights5.1 mi from City Center
From
US$ 765
/night
- Seasonal outdoor heated swimming pool
- Inviting outdoor fireplace for guests
- Bicycle rental for exploring Southold
- Beer Garden
- Oyster Lounge
- Event Space
2.6 mi from Shelter Island Heights2.6 mi from City Center
From
US$ 199
/night
- Accessible by land and sea
- Exclusive Beer Garden with local brews
- Oyster farm experience on-site
Bed & Breakfast
- Private beach
- Seasonal pool
- Gourmet breakfast
1.1 mi from Shelter Island Heights1.1 mi from City Center
From
US$ 625
/night
- Exceptional views of Greenport Harbor
- Personalized and attentive host service
- On-site heated swimming pool
Saved
Save
