Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights
Find the Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights – 5+ Quality Options from Leading Providers
1-5 out of 5 hotels
Sort by:
high popularity
- Price: low to high
- Price: high to low
- Guest rating: high to low
- Popularity: high to low
Hotel
8.6
Great2020 reviews10
MapView on map1500 yd from City Center1800 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 569
/night
Greenport Antique Carousel is around 2 miles from the 4-star Shelter Island House Shelter Island Heights and Dering Harbor Marina is approximately a 20-minute walk away.
Inn
8.6
Great2828 reviews10
MapView on map100 yd from City Center700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 826
/night
- On-site golf course
- Pets allowed
- Welcome drink offered
Guest house
7.6
Very good55 reviews10
- Family Rooms
- Bicycle Rentals
- Free Parking
From
US$ 358
/night
- Bicycle rentals available on-site
- Family rooms for larger groups
- Free private parking for guests
Bed & Breakfast
8.4
Great2828 reviews10
- Adirondack Chairs
- Personalized Service
- Local Dining
400 yd from City Center600 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 283
/night
- Intimate boutique atmosphere with historical charm
- King size beds for ultimate comfort
- Stunning creek views with outdoor seating
Bed & Breakfast
8.6
Great2020 reviews10
- On-site Gallery
- Spa Services
- Heated Pool
1400 yd from City Center1700 yd from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 270
/night
- On-site contemporary art gallery
- Private paradise near the Hamptons
- Luxurious spa services available
Saved
Save
Top Hotel Picks in Shelter Island Heights
How much is a room per night?
The hotels listed below are recommended for their proximity to Shelter Island beaches and parks, which are just minutes away. Average nightly rates start at $150, and many properties boast guest ratings of 8.0 or above.
3 star:
$150-$250
4 star:
$250-$400
5 star:
$400-$600