Top Hotels in Shelter Island
Find the Top Hotels in Shelter Island – 3+ Quality Options from Leading Providers
1-3 out of 3 hotels
Sort by:
high popularity
- Price: low to high
- Price: high to low
- Guest rating: high to low
- Popularity: high to low
Hotel
7.8
Very good2020 reviews10
MapView on map3.8 km from City Centre
From
US$ 407
/night
- Farm-to-table restaurant offerings
- Private beach with moorings
- Luxurious en suite accommodations
Hotel
8.6
Great5353 reviews10
MapView on map3.1 km from City Centre
From
US$ 334
/night
- Complimentary kayaks and paddleboards included
- Historic charm blended with modern amenities
- Lively BBQ nights promote guest interaction
Hotel
7.8
Very good2626 reviews10
- On-site Bar
- Beach Access
- Restaurant
2.3 km from City Centre
From
US$ 596
/night
- Vibrant summer party atmosphere
- On-site bar with self-produced Rosé
- European vibe with casual charm
Saved
Save
Top Hotel Picks in Shelter Island
How much is a room per night?
These hotels offer a mix of comfort and convenience, all within a short distance from the beaches and marinas. Prices start around $150 per night, with guest ratings typically above 8.0/10, making them solid choices for visitors.
3 star:
$150-$250
4 star:
$250-$400
5 star:
$400-$600
Top Recommended hotels in Shelter Island
Eastland Seaport Maritime, 3 km from the city center
Guests can enjoy two docks with boats available for hire, along with a restaurant serving a plated breakfast. The hotel offers a range of outdoor activities and is near the Crescent Beach area.
Manhansett Chapel Museum, 4 km from the city center
This historic inn features a restaurant and bar with a focus on seasonal ingredients. Guests can relax in a serene environment and enjoy a variety of events throughout their stay.
Eastland Seaport Maritime, 2 km from the city center
Located on a beachfront, this hotel offers modern rooms with complimentary Wi-Fi and an iPod docking station. Guests can enjoy French cuisine at the Sunset Beach Restaurant and explore the island with free bicycle rentals.