Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights
Find the Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights – 20+ Quality Options from Leading Providers
1-24 out of 24 hotels
Sort by:
high popularity
- Price: low to high
- Price: high to low
- Guest rating: high to low
- Popularity: high to low
Hotel
MapView on map1.3 km from City Centre1.6 km from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 569
/night
Set 3.8 km from Nova Constellatio Gallery, the smoke-free Shelter Island House offers 11 rooms and a seasonal outdoor swimming pool.
Bed & Breakfast
MapView on map400 m from City Centre600 m from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 458
/night
Fireboat Firefighter Museum is 10 minutes by car from the 4-star House On Chase Creek Bed & Breakfast and Lavender By the Bay is a 10-minute ride away.
Inn
100 m from City Centre600 m from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 826
/night
The Chequit Shelter Island Heights is situated at a distance of 2.7 km from Nova Constellatio Gallery and within 25 minutes' walk of Shelter Island.
Bed & Breakfast
- Art Gallery
- Bicycle Rental
- Heated Pool
1.3 km from City Centre1.6 km from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 870
/night
- On-site contemporary art gallery
- Luxury bicycle rental available
- Heated swimming pool outdoors
Hotel
- On-site Bar
- Beach Access
- Restaurant
1.5 km from City Centre1.9 km from Dering Harbor Marina
From
US$ 596
/night
- Vibrant summer party atmosphere
- On-site bar with self-produced Rosé
- European vibe with casual charm
Guest house
- Bicycle Rental
- Family Rooms
- Garden
From
US$ 358
/night
- Bicycle rental available on-site
- Air conditioning in all units
- Free private parking available
Places to stay near Shelter Island Heights
Hotel
2.0 km from Shelter Island Heights2.0 km from City Centre
From
US$ 499
/night
The Menhaden Greenport is situated approximately 2 km from Dering Harbor Marina and a mere 400 metres from East End Seaport Maritime Museum.
Hotel
- Outdoor pool
- Spa centre
- Bicycle rental
2.1 km from Shelter Island Heights2.1 km from City Centre
From
US$ 170
/night
- On-site golf course offering activities
- Heated outdoor swimming pool for families
- Bicycle and bike tours available
Motel
- Beach access
- Picnic area
- Sun terrace
5.0 km from Shelter Island Heights5.0 km from City Centre
From
US$ 250
/night
- Beachfront access with stunning views
- Spacious accommodations with kitchenettes
- Picnic area with grills and tables
Bed & Breakfast
4.7 km from Shelter Island Heights4.7 km from City Centre
From
US$ 325
/night
While staying at the budget Shorecrest Southold you are invited to discover Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum, set a 10-minute drive away, or Railroad Museum of Long Island, which is 4 km away.
- Outdoor Pool
- Kitchenette
- Fire Pit
4.6 km from Shelter Island Heights4.6 km from City Centre
From
US$ 186
/night
- Access to local wineries and vineyards
- Well-maintained outdoor BBQ facilities
- Community-oriented atmosphere for guests
Bed & Breakfast
- Garden Views
- Outdoor Dining
- Flat-Screen TV
6.1 km from Shelter Island Heights6.1 km from City Centre
From
US$ 355
/night
- Adults-only atmosphere for relaxation
- Garden views from the property
- Outdoor dining furniture available
Hotel
- Private beach
- Farm-to-table dining
- Event spaces
5.1 km from Shelter Island Heights5.1 km from City Centre
From
US$ 407
/night
- Farm-to-table restaurant offerings
- Private beach with moorings
- Luxurious en suite accommodations
Hotel
- Saltwater Pool
- Private Tennis Court
- On-site Dining
10.4 km from Shelter Island Heights10.4 km from City Centre
From
US$ 219
/night
- Dining with local ingredients and wine pairings
- Seasonal saltwater pool for relaxation
- Complimentary bicycles for local exploration
Hotel
- Outdoor pool
- Game room
- Private cottages
2.3 km from Shelter Island Heights2.3 km from City Centre
From
US$ 334
/night
- Complimentary kayaks and paddleboards included
- Historic charm blended with modern amenities
- Lively BBQ nights promote guest interaction
Hotel
- Culinary Academy
- Private Beach
- Piano Bar
3.7 km from Shelter Island Heights3.7 km from City Centre
From
US$ 541
/night
- Unique Culinary and Mixology Academies
- Direct Access to Private Beach
- Live Music in Piano Bar
Hotel
- On-site Restaurant
- Cocktail Bar
- Bicycle Rental
2.2 km from Shelter Island Heights2.2 km from City Centre
From
US$ 514
/night
- Award-winning seasonal American restaurant
- Boutique luxury in historic Stirling Square
- Dog-friendly accommodations available
Bed & Breakfast
2.3 km from Shelter Island Heights2.3 km from City Centre
From
US$ 447
/night
Dering Harbor Marina is approximately 2 km from 4-star The Stirling House and Greenport is only 12 minutes' walk away.
Bed & Breakfast
- Game room
- Bicycle rental
- Garden views
2.3 km from Shelter Island Heights2.3 km from City Centre
From
US$ 599
/night
- Bicycle rental for local exploration
- Family-friendly game room available
- Accessible facilities for all guests
- Beach Access
- Bicycle Rental
- Outdoor Seating
2.1 km from Shelter Island Heights2.1 km from City Centre
From
US$ 720
/night
- Bungalow-style accommodations for unique stays
- Exceptional service from passionate staff
- On-site restaurant with high-quality food
Hotel
3.4 km from Shelter Island Heights3.4 km from City Centre
From
US$ 1 117
/night
The 4-star Moraine Greenport is placed around a 25-minute walk from Railroad Museum of Long Island and near a train station.
4.2 km from Shelter Island Heights4.2 km from City Centre
From
US$ 199
/night
While staying at smoke-free The Shoals you are invited to discover Lavender By the Bay, set 7 km away, or Southold Bay, which is a 10-minute ride away.
Bed & Breakfast
1.7 km from Shelter Island Heights1.7 km from City Centre
From
US$ 625
/night
Set nearly 10 minutes' walk from Fireboat Firefighter Museum, the rooms in the 3-star Harbor Knoll have views of pool.
Bed & Breakfast
4.9 km from Shelter Island Heights4.9 km from City Centre
From
US$ 406
/night
Set about 10 minutes by car from Greenport Antique Carousel, the Arbor View East Marion boasts yoga classes, a picnic area, and barbecue grills available on site.
Saved
Save
